choosing who dies and who lives theme

A character faces a choice where every alternative leads to someone or other (at least two different people) dying.

38 total · 6 choice · 12 major · 20 minor

StoryLevelMotivation
ds94x05 choice Dukat had to kill his daughter Ziyal to save his family from suffering persecution at the hands of the Cardassian government
tng3x15 choice Enterprise-C crew goes back in the past to fight Klingons for the good of future generations
tos3x08 choice the aliens could save one but only one race, also McCoy and Spock about dying or insanity
tz1959e3x31 choice Central to the story was the tough decision of who would get to be young again.
tz2002e1x42 choice Five college students deliberated whom of them should be sacrificed to countermand an ancient Aztec curse.
voy5x11 choice The Doctor chose Harry's life over Ahni Jetal's
ds91x10 major Quark was repeatedly forced to make life and death decisions involving his friends
ds92x04 major Benjamin had to decide whether to shoot his old friend Verad or led his new friend Jadzia die
ent3x10 major Archer had to choose who between Tucker and the Tucker clone would die.
ftt1982e2x06 major The family thought they did not have enough food for everyone to survive. It was therefore decided that the children should be left in the woods for dead.